Hate 2025? Look Forward To These 2026 Mystery & Thrillers!

⚓ Books    📅 2025-09-17    👤 surdeus    👁️ 1      

surdeus

I accidentally read Emily Austin’s 2026 releasing novel, Is This a Cry For Help?, well before its publication date. How does one accidentally read a book in the year before it releases, you ask? I’m a big fan of Austin’s writing, so when I spotted an egalley for her 2026 novel, I immediately downloaded it and tossed it into my ereader’s “2026 TBR” folder. But then I did the I’ll-just-read-the-first-page-to-get-a-taste read, and whoopsie, I read the entire novel. 

I figured that since I’ve already started downloading (and reading!) 2026 titles, and have made my “2026 crime galley” doc, I’d give you a little peek into some of what I’ve already flagged. As usual, there’s plenty here for all the reading tastes, including a small-town cold case, a YA murder spree case, true crime, historical mysteries, and more!

*I did not put specific release dates because I don’t want to look like a liar if the release week or month changes, but they’re all listed in early 2026 catalogs.*

cover image for Last One Out by Jane Harper

Last One Out by Jane Harper

The second that I saw Jane Harper talking about her book tour and new novel releasing in Australia, I rushed to find when we’d get it in the US. Looks like Last One Out will be available in spring of 2026 (I already checked UK stores and, no, they’re not on the Australian pub date release schedule *cries).

Once again, we are getting an atmospheric, small Australian town setting, centering on a missing person case. Five years after her 21-year-old son disappears, Ro Crowley returns to Carralon Ridge for answers…

cover image for A Pretender's Murder by Christopher Huang

A Pretender’s Murder (Eric Peterkin #2) by Christopher Huang

Publishing continues to play musical chairs with release dates, so I’ve been excited about this sequel for a while and was super bummed when it got moved from 2025 to 2026 (publishing makes these decisions for a million reasons that have nothing to do with the quality of the book.)

I’ve talked about the first book in this series, A Gentleman’s Murder, a lot (including in Crime In Another Time: 17 Historical Mystery Books) and still recommend it regularly as a great historical, locked-room mystery! Naturally, I am thrilled to see that Eric Peterkin, who was editing a mystery novel and thought that qualified him as a great detective at the start of the series, is back! We’re still in London, 1920s, following WWI and the impact it’s had on society, including soldiers and their families. The exclusive Brittania club for soldiers once again is ground for a murder, and Peterkin must put his sleuthing cap on…

cover image for London Falling by Patrick Radden Keefe

London Falling: A Mysterious Death in a Gilded City and a Family’s Search for Truth by Patrick Radden Keefe

I will, and have, read everything PRK has written since Say Nothing: A True Story of Murder and Memory in Northern Ireland (bonus: there’s a great Hulu series adaptation), so I genuinely needed zero information to download this. And to be totally honest, the only reason I haven’t already read the galley is that I’m debating waiting for the audiobook.

Once again, we get a blend of history and crime from an excellent journalist and narrative nonfiction writer.

cover of Such A Perfect Family by Nalini Singh

Such A Perfect Family by Nalini Singh

If I wasn’t already a fan of Nalini Singh, I’d be 100% picking this up because of its setting and tropes!

Tavish Advani has a curious past: all his past relationships have ended with his partner dying. But this “kept man” didn’t let that slow him down. Having moved from L.A. to New Zealand with his new wife, things were looking up. Until his wife’s family home caught fire and exploded, leaving his wife and sister-in-law in a coma. What did his wife’s last words mean? Who would do this? Detectives have an eye on Tavish, but he wants to point at his new family.

cover image for I Don't Wish You Well by Jumata Emill

I Don’t Wish You Well by Jumata Emill

After having enjoyed both of Emill’s previous YA mysteries (The Black Queen, Wander in the Dark) I am obviously going to read any future titles. And the fact that it has many tropes I love has jumped it to the top of my TBR.

✔Teen investigative journalist.
✔Cold case murder mystery.
✔Small town murder spree.
✔Masked killer.

cover image for A Violent Masterpiece

A Violent Masterpiece by Jordan Harper

If you’ve been here for a little while, you know I love Harper’s crime novels (She Rides Shotgun, Everybody Knows), so hello, automatic buy/read for me!

This sounds like an intense L.A. crime novel that goes deep into its underbelly. It follows three strangers (“a gonzo live-streaming nightcrawler,” “a street lawyer,” and a private concierge employee) whose lives are all changed by a crime (a conspiracy, a questionable suicide, and a missing friend), who are all forced to decide how they’ll fight back in this violent world.

cover image for Crown City by Naomi Hirahara

Crown City by Naomi Hirahara

I have enjoyed Hirahara’s blend of history and mystery (Clark and Division and Evergreen) and was thrilled to see that she has a new novel releasing in early 2026. 

The history: 1903, Pasadena, Ryui arrives by boat from Japan as an 18-year-old orphan. 

The mystery: Ryui, working as an apprentice for an antiques dealer, and his roommate Jack, a photographer, are hired by an artist to find out who stole a painting from his studio. And the artist in the book is Toshio Aoki, who was a real-life Japanese artist!


Browse the books recommended in Unusual Suspects’ previous newsletters on this shelf and see 2025 releases. Check out this Unusual Suspects Pinterest board and get Tailored Book Recommendations! Until next time, come talk books with me on Bluesky, Goodreads, Litsy, and Multitudes Contained.

If a mystery fan forwarded this newsletter to you or you read it on bookriot.com and you’d like to get it right in your inbox, you can sign up here.

🏷️ Books_feed