TL/TR
Why are build results of my crate's test not consistent - I see rebuilds happen for combinations of these without changes in between?

• cargo build --all-targets
• cargo test -p create_a
• VSCode Test Explorer building tests for create_a

Background:

• we use a rust workspace ~40 creates as members
• cargo build --all-targets would build ~600 individual crates (i.e. dependencies + workspace crates)
• one of the crates in workspace "crate_a" would build ~300 individual creates (i.e. dev-dependencies + the crate's test itself)
• we have equivalent observation (see blow) no matter whether or not we use [workspace.dependencies] consistently (same versions and feature sets) for all creates in our workspace (including their dev-dependencies). (we tested for both cases)

Development practice

• We use VSCode with rust-analyzer extension as development tool on windows workstations.

• We use .vscode/settings.json having "rust-analyzer.testExplorer": true,

• we use any of these when we want to verify/debug test cases:

  • from terminal: {workspace_root} cargo test (for complete workspace)
  • from terminal: {workspace_root}/create_a cargo test (for individual crate in workspace)
  • CodeLens: run individual test cases with or without debug triggered from inside source code editor
  • Testing view (Test Explorer): run all or individual test cases triggered

• we usually do a {workspace_root} cargo build --all-targets before we run tests hoping for both:

  • a) quick feedback if your change compiles and doesn't break compilation of other test cases
  • b) have build results ready for running any number or selection of tests

We suffer from un-expected rebuilds (even without source code changes) in these scenarios. This way we suffer from slow turnaround times.

Observation
Here comes a scenario (Note: no changes to workspace happen in between)

• cargo clean
• cargo build --all-targets
  -> creates (among others) \target\debug\deps\crate_a-<hash_a>.exe
• cargo test -p crate_a
  -> (unexpected) rebuilds some dependencies and creates
  target\debug\deps\crate_a-<hash_b>.exe
• using test-lens to run a test case
  -> no rebuild (as expected), uses
  target\debug\deps\crate_a-<hash_b>.exe
• using test explorer
  -> (unexpected) rebuild some deps + *.exe
  -> seems to re-create
  (target\debug\deps\crate_a-<hash_b>.exe)
• using test-lens to run a test case
  -> (unexpected) rebuild some deps + *.exe
  -> seems to re-create
  (target\debug\deps\crate_a-<hash_b>.exe)
• cargo test -p dicom-bridge-poc-converters
  -> (as expected) no rebuild
  -> uses target\debug\deps\crate_a-<hash_b>.exe
• cd .crate_a
• cargo test
  -> no rebuild (as expected)
  -> uses target\debug\deps\crate_a-<hash_b>.exe
• using test lens
  -> (as expected) no rebuild
  -> uses target\debug\deps\crate_a-<hash_b>.exe
• using test explorer
  -> (unexpected) rebuild some deps + *.exe
  -> uses target\debug\deps\crate_a-<hash_b>.exe

Fazit
It seems there is an (for us) unexpected inconsistency/rebuild happening between
a) cargo build --all-targets (workspace) and the building/running crate_a's test
b) VS Code Test Explorer doesn't seem to 'accept' build result of create_a's test and re-creates it when alredy previously been build.

So for me it comes down to two questions

1. Why does cargo build --all-targets and individual builds via cargo test -p crate_a don't create/re-use the same build result?
2. Why does VS Codes's "Test Explorer" and the other ways to create build result for crate_a's do re-builds, even though thy apparently use the same build result?

1 post - 1 participant

Read full topic